CRITICISM by PRO RELIGIOUS ORGANISATIONS AGAINST DOCUMENT "SHAHBAG SHAHBAG"

 

Friends, after we showed our 1st response regarding document 'Shahbag Shahbag' to our critics, they mailed their views (religious) with some email instances from other renowned secular personalities like columnist Mr. Giasuddin. We are bound to make you know the status of this criticism. We think this will help us to understand how pro-religious organizations making wall against Secular movements in Bengal.

After we published our 1st post "Our Response" on 2nd August, a mail comes from CAAMB dated 6 August against our mail saying- 

"You talk about courage!!!!!!!!! Criticising Mullahs of Bangladesh and Hindutta in West Bengal sitting in Kolkata is the safest assignment on the earth. You have minimum guts challenge the Mullahs here, take example from great work being done by Giyasuddin." (picture given below)

In response to CAAMB's 6th August mail we got one more mail from well-known secular columnist Mr. Giasuddin. saying -

"Well done. Go ahead. No doubt, you are walking on the right track. We have to fight  Muslim communal forces, Hindu communal forces and other all communal forces . All are enemies to the mankind and civilization. But we should remember always that Muslim communal forces amongst the all communal forces are most dangerous. There are so many military organizations of the Muslim fundamentalist forces through out the world and they are working together to damage the peace and communal harmony to achieve their goal. Their goal is to bring the world under Islam and Shariat law. So, we have to give more emphasize against the Muslim communal forces than others. But that does not mean that we can ignore the danger of Hindu and other religious forces. I know very well that you are fully aware of it.

Thank you."  (picture given bellow)

We thought caamb will understand the message from Giasuddin so that they will stop hitting us. but we were wrong. They forwarded Giasuddin's mail by quoting "See Giasuddin's Response" (picture given bellow)

Situation like this no doubt makes people laugh. They thought Secular people like Giasuddin wrote "Well done, Go ahead" to them (to a pro-religious NGO like CAAMB). We wrote Giasuddin about this Fun-tastic incident. Mr. Giasuddin took it seriously and mailed us immediately clarifying his version on 7 August saying-

"Well done by publishing the book 'শাহবাগ শাহবাগ' . It is a valuable book no doubt to fight the religious communal forces. Go ahead. No doubt, you are walking on the right track. We have to fight  Muslim communal forces, Hindu communal forces and other all communal forces . All are enemies to the mankind and civilization. But we should remember always that Muslim communal forces amongst the all communal forces are most dangerous. There are so many military organizations of the Muslim fundamentalist forces through out the world and they are working together to damage the peace and communal harmony to achieve their goal. Their goal is to bring the world under Islam and Shariat law. So, we have to give more emphasize against the Muslim communal forces than others. But that does not mean that we can ignore the danger of Hindu and other religious forces. I know very well that you are fully aware of it.

Thank you."  . (picture given bellow)

Now friends we have a question to you- do you have any doubt what Mr. Giasuddin said about the book? We forwarded Giasuddin's mail to CAAMB so that they can understand and one more mail we wrote on 8 August addressing-

"Homework first, react next

Understandably truth is sometime difficult to digest, particularly when vegetarian stomach failed to digest non-veg foods. The arrogance for being a self-claimed Messiah for the Hindus of Bangladesh illustrate a number of prompt respond, ignoring the scholastic lesson- 'homework first and then go to school'. Initially when the debate started we thought it'll be a comparative and cognitive study for us and this organisation will have a minimum decency, transparency to react against any organisation. And as the polemic exhausted itself we also think, the pro-Islamist and pro-Hindutwa forces will bring to a halt against any type of hatred campaign against Shahabag Sanhati, Paschimbongo and Aamra Ek Sachetan Prayas. No, we fail to assume them, fail to gauge their swiftness to throw mud and malign.

They refer Giasuddin, misuse his quote (as a support for their organisational work) and also advice us to follow him to show a maximum guts to challenge fundamentalist. From the beginning we got privilege to work with him, in the field of activism, publishing and other relevant works. His first two books (Muslim Samaj banam Fotoa Santrasand Hizab: Nari Dasotwer Pratik) and newly publishable book 'Karbala: Myth o Mithya'  (Please follow our Face Book account) is inseparable from us. Their organisation, Dharmamukta Manabbadi Manch and its magazine,'Muktomon Muktokontho' is probably impossible to think without us. Our next programme, a seminar on 'Religion: The main obstacle for Humanity'(you all are welcome), dated 24^th August'13 is going to organise by Dharmamukto Manabbadi Mancha, Aamra..., and others. We are swollen with pride to be their comrade and also proud to be close with Giasuddin, the great reformer in this time. So friends (we still call you friend not foe), it is time from your part to take pardon for firstly not reading the book, Shahabag Shahabag with its full context (even not reading Giasuddin sincerely) and next giving instruction to others with a false claim (of Giasuddin comments).

“Don’t be satisfied with stories, how things have gone with others. Unfold your own myth.” -  Jalaluddin Rumi from Masnavi.

It is strictly for you, with respect." (picture given bellow)

 

We thought its clear like water to everyone like us. But we were wrong. CAAMB tried their tricks to frame Giasuddin as Anti-Islamist on their last mail to us. saying -

"Gias uddin wrote: "But we should remember always that Muslim communal forces amongst the all communal forces are most dangerous. ...... So, we have to give more emphasize against the Muslim communal forces than others." Learn to digest the truth of being friends of Islamic fundamentalists in the guise of secularism. So follow Giasuddin and learn from  http://caambkolkata.webnode.com

Otherwise get ready to live as jimmy in future." (picture given bellow)

May be soon we will response about this, but for now we are trying to realize how fast religious extremism is spreading by NGO like CAAMB and other pro religious organisations.

Thanks

Aamra Ek Sachetan Prayas